Why did Black Widow give the spear to Proxima?
After Natasha wounded Corvus Glaive in Avengers: Infinity War, she threw the spear to Proxima.
Was it accidental or intentional? If intentional, then for what purpose?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
add a comment |
After Natasha wounded Corvus Glaive in Avengers: Infinity War, she threw the spear to Proxima.
Was it accidental or intentional? If intentional, then for what purpose?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
1
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago
add a comment |
After Natasha wounded Corvus Glaive in Avengers: Infinity War, she threw the spear to Proxima.
Was it accidental or intentional? If intentional, then for what purpose?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
After Natasha wounded Corvus Glaive in Avengers: Infinity War, she threw the spear to Proxima.
Was it accidental or intentional? If intentional, then for what purpose?
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war
plot-explanation marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
edited Jan 1 at 16:53
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
83.9k16292280
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
asked Jan 1 at 16:12
Ver Nick
9701628
9701628
1
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago
add a comment |
1
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago
1
1
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
It wasn't thrown...it was pulled away.
At least that's the way it appears....Proxima appears to call the spear to her so she can use it as a weapon.
It certainly looks, to me, as though it was pulled from Natasha's grasp rather than being thrown backwards.
There is a "transcript" at a Wikia (so not official) which would seem to confirm this that I am not alone in this impression...
[At the same time, Captain America throws Proxima's weapon to Natasha Romanoff (Black Widow) who engages Corvus, ducking under his swing, stabbing him in the gut and executing a flying kick to knock him backwards.]
[Proxima, who has rushed back to the fight, summons her weapon back to her hand and attacks Black Widow. Captain America leaps forward, rolls, scoops up Corvus's dropped glaive and holds her off.
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
It wasn't thrown...it was pulled away.
At least that's the way it appears....Proxima appears to call the spear to her so she can use it as a weapon.
It certainly looks, to me, as though it was pulled from Natasha's grasp rather than being thrown backwards.
There is a "transcript" at a Wikia (so not official) which would seem to confirm this that I am not alone in this impression...
[At the same time, Captain America throws Proxima's weapon to Natasha Romanoff (Black Widow) who engages Corvus, ducking under his swing, stabbing him in the gut and executing a flying kick to knock him backwards.]
[Proxima, who has rushed back to the fight, summons her weapon back to her hand and attacks Black Widow. Captain America leaps forward, rolls, scoops up Corvus's dropped glaive and holds her off.
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
add a comment |
It wasn't thrown...it was pulled away.
At least that's the way it appears....Proxima appears to call the spear to her so she can use it as a weapon.
It certainly looks, to me, as though it was pulled from Natasha's grasp rather than being thrown backwards.
There is a "transcript" at a Wikia (so not official) which would seem to confirm this that I am not alone in this impression...
[At the same time, Captain America throws Proxima's weapon to Natasha Romanoff (Black Widow) who engages Corvus, ducking under his swing, stabbing him in the gut and executing a flying kick to knock him backwards.]
[Proxima, who has rushed back to the fight, summons her weapon back to her hand and attacks Black Widow. Captain America leaps forward, rolls, scoops up Corvus's dropped glaive and holds her off.
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
add a comment |
It wasn't thrown...it was pulled away.
At least that's the way it appears....Proxima appears to call the spear to her so she can use it as a weapon.
It certainly looks, to me, as though it was pulled from Natasha's grasp rather than being thrown backwards.
There is a "transcript" at a Wikia (so not official) which would seem to confirm this that I am not alone in this impression...
[At the same time, Captain America throws Proxima's weapon to Natasha Romanoff (Black Widow) who engages Corvus, ducking under his swing, stabbing him in the gut and executing a flying kick to knock him backwards.]
[Proxima, who has rushed back to the fight, summons her weapon back to her hand and attacks Black Widow. Captain America leaps forward, rolls, scoops up Corvus's dropped glaive and holds her off.
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
It wasn't thrown...it was pulled away.
At least that's the way it appears....Proxima appears to call the spear to her so she can use it as a weapon.
It certainly looks, to me, as though it was pulled from Natasha's grasp rather than being thrown backwards.
There is a "transcript" at a Wikia (so not official) which would seem to confirm this that I am not alone in this impression...
[At the same time, Captain America throws Proxima's weapon to Natasha Romanoff (Black Widow) who engages Corvus, ducking under his swing, stabbing him in the gut and executing a flying kick to knock him backwards.]
[Proxima, who has rushed back to the fight, summons her weapon back to her hand and attacks Black Widow. Captain America leaps forward, rolls, scoops up Corvus's dropped glaive and holds her off.
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
edited Jan 1 at 17:09
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
answered Jan 1 at 16:46
Paulie_D
83.9k16292280
83.9k16292280
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
add a comment |
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
12
12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
Obviously pulled from her hand. The spear flies backward from where she's looking, one doesn't throw like that. Also the timing is just right before she can use the spear to finish off the fallen fella.
– ilkkachu
Jan 1 at 18:12
9
9
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
When they get beamed back into their ship, a spear also gets yanked out of Captain America's hand.
– Stephen S
Jan 2 at 1:55
2
2
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
@StephenS I think Cap had Corvious' weapon, not Proxima's spear
– Vishwa
Jan 2 at 5:15
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
After this, we can also see that the spear escaped from Cap.
– Ver Nick
yesterday
add a comment |
1
Her face says it's pulled away. Her wist and arm mouvement says : not enought range for that kind of throw so it's pulled. The trajectory says it's pulled but not to the carrier hand but into her leap trajectory. Even Thor Hammer doesn't have this predictive trajectory feature. The real question is what if someone grab her feet and stop her from reaching the apex of the leap and grab the spear. Does it fly to infinity ?
– xdtTransform
2 days ago