What changes were done with Sailor Moon to make it heteronormative?












34















I have a blurred memory of watching Sailor Moon, American dub version, and had no memory of any homosexual story arc or characters. Recently I learned it was considered one of the only strong positive homosexual representations and had characters with lesbian and gay couples in prominent roles.



While researching I learned the American version censored it a lot to remove any sign of homosexual themes. How is that achieved when the main characters were also gay and lesbian? What were all the changes done to achieve this?










share|improve this question




















  • 2





    Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

    – Anoplexian
    Dec 18 '18 at 16:29
















34















I have a blurred memory of watching Sailor Moon, American dub version, and had no memory of any homosexual story arc or characters. Recently I learned it was considered one of the only strong positive homosexual representations and had characters with lesbian and gay couples in prominent roles.



While researching I learned the American version censored it a lot to remove any sign of homosexual themes. How is that achieved when the main characters were also gay and lesbian? What were all the changes done to achieve this?










share|improve this question




















  • 2





    Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

    – Anoplexian
    Dec 18 '18 at 16:29














34












34








34


4






I have a blurred memory of watching Sailor Moon, American dub version, and had no memory of any homosexual story arc or characters. Recently I learned it was considered one of the only strong positive homosexual representations and had characters with lesbian and gay couples in prominent roles.



While researching I learned the American version censored it a lot to remove any sign of homosexual themes. How is that achieved when the main characters were also gay and lesbian? What were all the changes done to achieve this?










share|improve this question
















I have a blurred memory of watching Sailor Moon, American dub version, and had no memory of any homosexual story arc or characters. Recently I learned it was considered one of the only strong positive homosexual representations and had characters with lesbian and gay couples in prominent roles.



While researching I learned the American version censored it a lot to remove any sign of homosexual themes. How is that achieved when the main characters were also gay and lesbian? What were all the changes done to achieve this?







censorship sailor-moon






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Dec 18 '18 at 18:43









Booga Roo

1257




1257










asked Dec 17 '18 at 7:10









Ankit SharmaAnkit Sharma

73.6k62386595




73.6k62386595








  • 2





    Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

    – Anoplexian
    Dec 18 '18 at 16:29














  • 2





    Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

    – Anoplexian
    Dec 18 '18 at 16:29








2




2





Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

– Anoplexian
Dec 18 '18 at 16:29





Thanks for asking, I had no idea that the American version of Sailor Moon was so LGBT unfriendly. I'll have to go back and watch the Japanese version to see the differences.

– Anoplexian
Dec 18 '18 at 16:29










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















46














Following changes were done to remove homosexuality elements.



From Screenrant,






  1. Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus Went From Girlfriends To Cousins:




    Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus were originally lesbian lovers in the Japanese version of Sailor Moon but the company changed it so the two referred to each other as cousins. Let the awkwardness ensue! The two act awfully close for "cousins," often holding hands and giving each other quite meaningful looks. So they went from a lesbian couple, a great example of positive LGBT representation in mainstream anime, to "platonic" cousins.



    Interestingly, some dubs outside of the United States kept the relationship between the two alive but gave Sailor Uranus a male voice actor, trying to turn her into a male character. This may have made some viewers scratch their heads when the now male Uranus transformed into a Sailor Scout form, which came with a much more feminine physical appearance and skirt.





  2. Zoisite Changed From A Gay Man To A Straight Woman:




    Just like some dubs in other countries made Sailor Uranus male so she could continue her relationship with Neptune as a heterosexual couple, the English dub made Zoisite, one of Queen Beryl's warriors, change from a gay man to a straight female. In the Japanese version, he is lovers with another warrior under Queen Beryl's command, Kunzite. This relationship was actually a creation of the anime, since the original manga actually portrays the two to be as close as brothers and not lovers.







Also the American version edited the two-part finale of the first season heavily to remove any violence which resulted into one single episode. They also didn't release Sailor Stars, Sailor Moon Stars, the fifth season of the original show. Besides this, there were heavy name changes to make it Americanized.



From The Gamer (emphasis mine),




In the original Japanese anime and manga series, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were always open about their lesbian relationship. Their romantic involvement is well-known to most anime fans. Though they both flirted with the other characters or men, at the end of the day, they love each other the most. They even go so far as to become parents to Sailor Saturn, calling themselves "papa" and "mama."



American censors changed the famous LBGT couple from being lesbians to straight. When speaking of first kisses, they both mention men. Michelle mentions kissing a boy named Brad in Junior High school, but during the flashback, it's a shadowy figure of Amara. Their relationship was changed from a lesbian couple to close cousins in the American localization.







share|improve this answer

































    10














    Just to add to the other answer, The final series arc post Sailor Moon SuperS, titled Sailor Moon Sailor Stars was completely excluded from the American version.








    The story line featured 3 Sailor Soldiers from outerspace, The Sailor Starlights, posing as male Pop Stars. They are looking to stop another Sailor senshi/soldier, Sailor Galaxia from becoming the most power senshi in the galaxy by steeling human's of Earth's star seeds. When they transformed into sailor soldiers, they transform from men into women and one of the characters, Seiya had a massive crush on Usagi (Sailor Moon), as Mamoru (Tuxedo Mask) is absent for part of the story line...



    Moon saves Galaxia




    This series was not dubbed during the original run of the English dub
    because around the mid-2000s, the license for this season was cut off
    by Toei Animation from being distributed anywhere outside Japan
    ; a
    common misconception was that it was because of the genderbending
    nature of the Sailor Starlights, which wouldn't get past American
    censors due to possibly promoting transgender and homosexual themes.




    Although it's been sited this exclusion was do to Toei Animation licensing issue, there are many who argue it was also for other reasons, such as the genderbending aspects, more violent then previous series, and whose former religious undertones become more overt and materialize, as Sailor Moon gains "wings" and becomes The Messiah.





    The argument seems valid to me, given the way Viz handled the former source material.






    share|improve this answer































      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes








      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      46














      Following changes were done to remove homosexuality elements.



      From Screenrant,






      1. Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus Went From Girlfriends To Cousins:




        Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus were originally lesbian lovers in the Japanese version of Sailor Moon but the company changed it so the two referred to each other as cousins. Let the awkwardness ensue! The two act awfully close for "cousins," often holding hands and giving each other quite meaningful looks. So they went from a lesbian couple, a great example of positive LGBT representation in mainstream anime, to "platonic" cousins.



        Interestingly, some dubs outside of the United States kept the relationship between the two alive but gave Sailor Uranus a male voice actor, trying to turn her into a male character. This may have made some viewers scratch their heads when the now male Uranus transformed into a Sailor Scout form, which came with a much more feminine physical appearance and skirt.





      2. Zoisite Changed From A Gay Man To A Straight Woman:




        Just like some dubs in other countries made Sailor Uranus male so she could continue her relationship with Neptune as a heterosexual couple, the English dub made Zoisite, one of Queen Beryl's warriors, change from a gay man to a straight female. In the Japanese version, he is lovers with another warrior under Queen Beryl's command, Kunzite. This relationship was actually a creation of the anime, since the original manga actually portrays the two to be as close as brothers and not lovers.







      Also the American version edited the two-part finale of the first season heavily to remove any violence which resulted into one single episode. They also didn't release Sailor Stars, Sailor Moon Stars, the fifth season of the original show. Besides this, there were heavy name changes to make it Americanized.



      From The Gamer (emphasis mine),




      In the original Japanese anime and manga series, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were always open about their lesbian relationship. Their romantic involvement is well-known to most anime fans. Though they both flirted with the other characters or men, at the end of the day, they love each other the most. They even go so far as to become parents to Sailor Saturn, calling themselves "papa" and "mama."



      American censors changed the famous LBGT couple from being lesbians to straight. When speaking of first kisses, they both mention men. Michelle mentions kissing a boy named Brad in Junior High school, but during the flashback, it's a shadowy figure of Amara. Their relationship was changed from a lesbian couple to close cousins in the American localization.







      share|improve this answer






























        46














        Following changes were done to remove homosexuality elements.



        From Screenrant,






        1. Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus Went From Girlfriends To Cousins:




          Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus were originally lesbian lovers in the Japanese version of Sailor Moon but the company changed it so the two referred to each other as cousins. Let the awkwardness ensue! The two act awfully close for "cousins," often holding hands and giving each other quite meaningful looks. So they went from a lesbian couple, a great example of positive LGBT representation in mainstream anime, to "platonic" cousins.



          Interestingly, some dubs outside of the United States kept the relationship between the two alive but gave Sailor Uranus a male voice actor, trying to turn her into a male character. This may have made some viewers scratch their heads when the now male Uranus transformed into a Sailor Scout form, which came with a much more feminine physical appearance and skirt.





        2. Zoisite Changed From A Gay Man To A Straight Woman:




          Just like some dubs in other countries made Sailor Uranus male so she could continue her relationship with Neptune as a heterosexual couple, the English dub made Zoisite, one of Queen Beryl's warriors, change from a gay man to a straight female. In the Japanese version, he is lovers with another warrior under Queen Beryl's command, Kunzite. This relationship was actually a creation of the anime, since the original manga actually portrays the two to be as close as brothers and not lovers.







        Also the American version edited the two-part finale of the first season heavily to remove any violence which resulted into one single episode. They also didn't release Sailor Stars, Sailor Moon Stars, the fifth season of the original show. Besides this, there were heavy name changes to make it Americanized.



        From The Gamer (emphasis mine),




        In the original Japanese anime and manga series, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were always open about their lesbian relationship. Their romantic involvement is well-known to most anime fans. Though they both flirted with the other characters or men, at the end of the day, they love each other the most. They even go so far as to become parents to Sailor Saturn, calling themselves "papa" and "mama."



        American censors changed the famous LBGT couple from being lesbians to straight. When speaking of first kisses, they both mention men. Michelle mentions kissing a boy named Brad in Junior High school, but during the flashback, it's a shadowy figure of Amara. Their relationship was changed from a lesbian couple to close cousins in the American localization.







        share|improve this answer




























          46












          46








          46







          Following changes were done to remove homosexuality elements.



          From Screenrant,






          1. Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus Went From Girlfriends To Cousins:




            Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus were originally lesbian lovers in the Japanese version of Sailor Moon but the company changed it so the two referred to each other as cousins. Let the awkwardness ensue! The two act awfully close for "cousins," often holding hands and giving each other quite meaningful looks. So they went from a lesbian couple, a great example of positive LGBT representation in mainstream anime, to "platonic" cousins.



            Interestingly, some dubs outside of the United States kept the relationship between the two alive but gave Sailor Uranus a male voice actor, trying to turn her into a male character. This may have made some viewers scratch their heads when the now male Uranus transformed into a Sailor Scout form, which came with a much more feminine physical appearance and skirt.





          2. Zoisite Changed From A Gay Man To A Straight Woman:




            Just like some dubs in other countries made Sailor Uranus male so she could continue her relationship with Neptune as a heterosexual couple, the English dub made Zoisite, one of Queen Beryl's warriors, change from a gay man to a straight female. In the Japanese version, he is lovers with another warrior under Queen Beryl's command, Kunzite. This relationship was actually a creation of the anime, since the original manga actually portrays the two to be as close as brothers and not lovers.







          Also the American version edited the two-part finale of the first season heavily to remove any violence which resulted into one single episode. They also didn't release Sailor Stars, Sailor Moon Stars, the fifth season of the original show. Besides this, there were heavy name changes to make it Americanized.



          From The Gamer (emphasis mine),




          In the original Japanese anime and manga series, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were always open about their lesbian relationship. Their romantic involvement is well-known to most anime fans. Though they both flirted with the other characters or men, at the end of the day, they love each other the most. They even go so far as to become parents to Sailor Saturn, calling themselves "papa" and "mama."



          American censors changed the famous LBGT couple from being lesbians to straight. When speaking of first kisses, they both mention men. Michelle mentions kissing a boy named Brad in Junior High school, but during the flashback, it's a shadowy figure of Amara. Their relationship was changed from a lesbian couple to close cousins in the American localization.







          share|improve this answer















          Following changes were done to remove homosexuality elements.



          From Screenrant,






          1. Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus Went From Girlfriends To Cousins:




            Sailor Neptune and Sailor Uranus were originally lesbian lovers in the Japanese version of Sailor Moon but the company changed it so the two referred to each other as cousins. Let the awkwardness ensue! The two act awfully close for "cousins," often holding hands and giving each other quite meaningful looks. So they went from a lesbian couple, a great example of positive LGBT representation in mainstream anime, to "platonic" cousins.



            Interestingly, some dubs outside of the United States kept the relationship between the two alive but gave Sailor Uranus a male voice actor, trying to turn her into a male character. This may have made some viewers scratch their heads when the now male Uranus transformed into a Sailor Scout form, which came with a much more feminine physical appearance and skirt.





          2. Zoisite Changed From A Gay Man To A Straight Woman:




            Just like some dubs in other countries made Sailor Uranus male so she could continue her relationship with Neptune as a heterosexual couple, the English dub made Zoisite, one of Queen Beryl's warriors, change from a gay man to a straight female. In the Japanese version, he is lovers with another warrior under Queen Beryl's command, Kunzite. This relationship was actually a creation of the anime, since the original manga actually portrays the two to be as close as brothers and not lovers.







          Also the American version edited the two-part finale of the first season heavily to remove any violence which resulted into one single episode. They also didn't release Sailor Stars, Sailor Moon Stars, the fifth season of the original show. Besides this, there were heavy name changes to make it Americanized.



          From The Gamer (emphasis mine),




          In the original Japanese anime and manga series, Sailor Uranus and Sailor Neptune were always open about their lesbian relationship. Their romantic involvement is well-known to most anime fans. Though they both flirted with the other characters or men, at the end of the day, they love each other the most. They even go so far as to become parents to Sailor Saturn, calling themselves "papa" and "mama."



          American censors changed the famous LBGT couple from being lesbians to straight. When speaking of first kisses, they both mention men. Michelle mentions kissing a boy named Brad in Junior High school, but during the flashback, it's a shadowy figure of Amara. Their relationship was changed from a lesbian couple to close cousins in the American localization.








          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Dec 17 '18 at 17:35









          Napoleon Wilson

          41.7k38268510




          41.7k38268510










          answered Dec 17 '18 at 7:12









          A JA J

          40.7k16220234




          40.7k16220234























              10














              Just to add to the other answer, The final series arc post Sailor Moon SuperS, titled Sailor Moon Sailor Stars was completely excluded from the American version.








              The story line featured 3 Sailor Soldiers from outerspace, The Sailor Starlights, posing as male Pop Stars. They are looking to stop another Sailor senshi/soldier, Sailor Galaxia from becoming the most power senshi in the galaxy by steeling human's of Earth's star seeds. When they transformed into sailor soldiers, they transform from men into women and one of the characters, Seiya had a massive crush on Usagi (Sailor Moon), as Mamoru (Tuxedo Mask) is absent for part of the story line...



              Moon saves Galaxia




              This series was not dubbed during the original run of the English dub
              because around the mid-2000s, the license for this season was cut off
              by Toei Animation from being distributed anywhere outside Japan
              ; a
              common misconception was that it was because of the genderbending
              nature of the Sailor Starlights, which wouldn't get past American
              censors due to possibly promoting transgender and homosexual themes.




              Although it's been sited this exclusion was do to Toei Animation licensing issue, there are many who argue it was also for other reasons, such as the genderbending aspects, more violent then previous series, and whose former religious undertones become more overt and materialize, as Sailor Moon gains "wings" and becomes The Messiah.





              The argument seems valid to me, given the way Viz handled the former source material.






              share|improve this answer




























                10














                Just to add to the other answer, The final series arc post Sailor Moon SuperS, titled Sailor Moon Sailor Stars was completely excluded from the American version.








                The story line featured 3 Sailor Soldiers from outerspace, The Sailor Starlights, posing as male Pop Stars. They are looking to stop another Sailor senshi/soldier, Sailor Galaxia from becoming the most power senshi in the galaxy by steeling human's of Earth's star seeds. When they transformed into sailor soldiers, they transform from men into women and one of the characters, Seiya had a massive crush on Usagi (Sailor Moon), as Mamoru (Tuxedo Mask) is absent for part of the story line...



                Moon saves Galaxia




                This series was not dubbed during the original run of the English dub
                because around the mid-2000s, the license for this season was cut off
                by Toei Animation from being distributed anywhere outside Japan
                ; a
                common misconception was that it was because of the genderbending
                nature of the Sailor Starlights, which wouldn't get past American
                censors due to possibly promoting transgender and homosexual themes.




                Although it's been sited this exclusion was do to Toei Animation licensing issue, there are many who argue it was also for other reasons, such as the genderbending aspects, more violent then previous series, and whose former religious undertones become more overt and materialize, as Sailor Moon gains "wings" and becomes The Messiah.





                The argument seems valid to me, given the way Viz handled the former source material.






                share|improve this answer


























                  10












                  10








                  10







                  Just to add to the other answer, The final series arc post Sailor Moon SuperS, titled Sailor Moon Sailor Stars was completely excluded from the American version.








                  The story line featured 3 Sailor Soldiers from outerspace, The Sailor Starlights, posing as male Pop Stars. They are looking to stop another Sailor senshi/soldier, Sailor Galaxia from becoming the most power senshi in the galaxy by steeling human's of Earth's star seeds. When they transformed into sailor soldiers, they transform from men into women and one of the characters, Seiya had a massive crush on Usagi (Sailor Moon), as Mamoru (Tuxedo Mask) is absent for part of the story line...



                  Moon saves Galaxia




                  This series was not dubbed during the original run of the English dub
                  because around the mid-2000s, the license for this season was cut off
                  by Toei Animation from being distributed anywhere outside Japan
                  ; a
                  common misconception was that it was because of the genderbending
                  nature of the Sailor Starlights, which wouldn't get past American
                  censors due to possibly promoting transgender and homosexual themes.




                  Although it's been sited this exclusion was do to Toei Animation licensing issue, there are many who argue it was also for other reasons, such as the genderbending aspects, more violent then previous series, and whose former religious undertones become more overt and materialize, as Sailor Moon gains "wings" and becomes The Messiah.





                  The argument seems valid to me, given the way Viz handled the former source material.






                  share|improve this answer













                  Just to add to the other answer, The final series arc post Sailor Moon SuperS, titled Sailor Moon Sailor Stars was completely excluded from the American version.








                  The story line featured 3 Sailor Soldiers from outerspace, The Sailor Starlights, posing as male Pop Stars. They are looking to stop another Sailor senshi/soldier, Sailor Galaxia from becoming the most power senshi in the galaxy by steeling human's of Earth's star seeds. When they transformed into sailor soldiers, they transform from men into women and one of the characters, Seiya had a massive crush on Usagi (Sailor Moon), as Mamoru (Tuxedo Mask) is absent for part of the story line...



                  Moon saves Galaxia




                  This series was not dubbed during the original run of the English dub
                  because around the mid-2000s, the license for this season was cut off
                  by Toei Animation from being distributed anywhere outside Japan
                  ; a
                  common misconception was that it was because of the genderbending
                  nature of the Sailor Starlights, which wouldn't get past American
                  censors due to possibly promoting transgender and homosexual themes.




                  Although it's been sited this exclusion was do to Toei Animation licensing issue, there are many who argue it was also for other reasons, such as the genderbending aspects, more violent then previous series, and whose former religious undertones become more overt and materialize, as Sailor Moon gains "wings" and becomes The Messiah.





                  The argument seems valid to me, given the way Viz handled the former source material.















                  share|improve this answer












                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer










                  answered Dec 17 '18 at 16:50









                  Darth LockeDarth Locke

                  10.8k12360




                  10.8k12360















                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Сан-Квентин

                      8-я гвардейская общевойсковая армия

                      Алькесар